Welcome to FanIQ!
FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.
Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,328,691+ Comments
Track your game picks - 15,027,509+ Sports Predictions
Prove you know sports - 79,935+ Trivia Questions
Find fans of your teams - 3,222,916+ New Friends

Next Post »
« Previous Post

MLB All-Star Game: Who Got Snubbed
28
comments
Seriously, Where's Pat Burrell?
by gearhead
>7 days ago

Just like every year when the All-Star teams are announced, there's numerous complaints about who got snubbed and who shouldn't be in. We've already seen that with the inexplicable Jason Varitek selection. Just like ever year though, we'll all forget two days after the game is played. For the time being, who has a legit reason to feel snubbed?

American League

Evan Longoria, Rays
: There's been some complaints about first place Tampa Bay only getting two All-Star. Longoria can still make it three if he wins the Final Vote. If he doesn't though (likely with Giambi on that list), Longoria will be the biggest AL snub. The rookie has hit the bigs running, hitting .283/.354/.535, with 16 homers. His OPS+ of the 138 leads the Rays, who are of course the best first half story and turnaround in baseball. Longoria was passed over in favor of Carlos Guillen and Joe Crede. Guillen is the only Tiger, but why is Crede and his 114 OPS+ there over Longoria?

Brian Roberts, Orioles: I know, I'm a homer. However, Roberts is second among AL second basemen in OPS, leads the entire AL in triples, and is fourth in the AL in stolen bases. Pedroia and Kinsler are the only second basemen on the roster. Roberts could have easily made it three, and should have been the token Oriole over closer George Sherill. Sherill is only there due to his saves, even though his ERA isn't that great and most of his saves end up being adventures that raise all O's fans blood pressures.

Jermaine Dye, White Sox: Normally you'd think being second among AL outfielders in OPS and tied for second in the league in homers while being on a surprising first place team would be enough for an All-Star berth. Not for Dye, who's left on the Final Man ballot. Dye, along with Carlos Quentin, has kept the White Sox offense afloat while guys like Thome and Konerko have struggled. Problem is, it's hard to take out any of the current outfielders, so Dye's best chance is probably replacing the injured Ortiz.

Felix Hernandez, Mariners: King Felix currently ranks 5th in the AL in ERA among starters, with a very nice 2.83. Now, admittedly John Danks and Shawn Marcum have better ERAs, but which of those three would you rather see? Hernandez is also 10th in strikeouts. Hernandez got screwed because Ichiro was voted in to be the M's rep, and the new trend towards taking as many closers as starters.

Jon Lester, Red Sox: Lester has been the Sox best starter all season. He ranks 8th in ERA and 8th in inning pitched. Oh, he also threw a no-hitter. Oh, and he's beaten cancer. Given his contributions to his team plus his story, I'm surprised Francona didn't take him. Yes, there are already a lot of Red Sox. I'm sure (Varitek) one of them (Varitek) could be taken out (Varitek) to make room for Lester (Varitek). Who could it be (Varitek)?

National League

Pat Burrell, Phillies
: I know. His defense and baserunning are atrocious at best. However, Pat the Bat has been tearing the cover off the ball all year. He ranks sixth in the NL in OPS, behind only Chipper, Berkman, Pujols, Holliday, and Uggla. Burrell (who is on the Final Man ballot) got passed over thanks to Soriano, Fukudome, and Braun being voted in, McLouth being the sole Pirate, and Ryan Ludwick getting a nod despite screaming first half fluke (as shown by his horrible June). Burrell's had a better season than all five of those outfielders.

Jose Reyes, Mets: Yes, the Mets are underachieving, but Reyes is not among those. He ranks 3rd in OPS among NL shortstops, behind Hanley Ramirez and JJ Hardy. Again, between Reyes and Hardy, who do you want to see? Reyes also leads the NL in stolen bases and triples. Reyes got passed over by Cristian Guzman and Miguel Tejada. Guzman is the token National in every sense of the word. There is no other worthy in any way. However, how did Tejada (hitting .280/.323/.436) make it over Reyes (hitting .299/.360/.485)? Berkman's on the team, so Tejada isn't the token Astro.

Jason Bay, Pirates: No one's noticed, but Bay is having a great year, hitting .289/.395/.527, with 17 homers (only 45 RBIs, but it is the Pirates after all). Bay probably would've made a better Pirate rep than McLouth, but team construction might have played a factor here. McLouth is the only true centerfielder on the NL team.

Johan Santana, Mets: The New York media thinks he's a bust, but a 2.96 ERA and 109 K's is not bust level performance. Santana ranks 5th in ERA, 3rd in inning pitched, and 5th in strikeouts. Was his 7-7 record really the reason he was left off?

Cole Hamels, Phillies: This might be a bigger screwjob than Santana. Hamels this year is 9-5 with a 3.22 ERA and 110 strikeouts in 128.2 innings. That makes Hamels 10th in ERA, 4th in strikeouts, and 2nd in innings pitched. Hamels got squeezed out by the closer fetish, particularly the strange selection of Brian Wilson, the worst NL All-Star. Wilson is on there because he has 24 saves, which leads the National League. That's the only reason, since his ERA is 4.37, terrible for a relief pitcher. He's not the token Giant either, since Lincecum is on the roster. Either Hamels or Santana would've worked over Wilson.

Who do you feel is this year's biggest All-Star snub?
FanIQ Says... (66)
All-Star Game Snubs
Who do you think were the biggest All-Star snubs in each league?
(Q1 of 2) American League
45% Evan Longoria
3% Brian Roberts
24% Jermaine Dye
0% Felix Hernandez
6% Jon Lester
21% Other
Asked by: gearhead
Asked >7 days ago

28
Comment!
Share it

Read More: MLB, 2008 MLB All-Star Game
« Wings (temporarily) Abandon Lord Stanley On Malibu Beach | NASCAR STREAKING Poll Update (Session II - Race 4 of 12; Results) »

TODAY'S TOP PICKS ON FANIQ
  1. Little Doubt Who Belongs On Top, The Rest Is More Complicated 3
  2. Will The Real Colt McCoy Please Stand Up? 8
  3. Kobe Bryant Rules China With An Iron Fist 2
  4. Jacques Rogges Does Not Approve Of This
  5. Jay Mariotti Doesn't Want to Become More Obsolete Than He Already Is, Resigns From the Newspaper Biz 7
Who Am I?
Who Am I?
Take the Trivia Challenge

Joe Louis
Mike Tyson
Muhammad Ali
George Foreman

Created by: Jon
More Sports Trivia
28 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment
Top comment earns 300 Points!
+300 points!
50 days ago
4
VOTE:
 
+4
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
I know I am going to get killed for this but I honestly believe that Brandon Phillips of the Reds got snubbed.  He is the best defensive 2B in the league and he is going to drive in 100 runs and possibly score 100 runs for a bad team.  I get why Ugla and Utley are there and they deserve it but Phillips deserves to be there also.
 
50 days ago
3
VOTE:
 
+3
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
Kerry Wood and Billy Wagner making it is a joke.  But the people who got snubbed are Evan Longoria if he doesn't win the final vote, Cole Hamels!!, and Pat Burrell if he doesn't win the final vote either.
 
50 days ago
4
VOTE:
 
+4
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
I know I am going to get killed for this but I honestly believe that Brandon Phillips of the Reds got snubbed.  He is the best defensive 2B in the league and he is going to drive in 100 runs and possibly score 100 runs for a bad team.  I get why Ugla and Utley are there and they deserve it but Phillips deserves to be there also.
 
50 days ago
0
VOTE:
 
+0
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
Look I am doing my best to stuff the ballot box for Jermaine Dye. Lord willing it will work.
 
50 days ago
2
VOTE:
 
+2
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
Take out Crede for Longoria and Varitek for Pierzynski.  Also, Miguel Tejada for Jose Reyes.
 
49 days ago
2
VOTE:
 
+0
 
+2
 
+0
 
-1
Why does this article not mention David Wright? Best-hitting 3B in the league! (Anyone who says "Chipper Jones" and ".380" gets a punch for being shallower than a fresh puddle.)
 
49 days ago
0
VOTE:
 
+0
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0

Sentimental choice for me is Mike Mussina.  He is 11-6 with a 3.64.  The Yanks have scored 3 or fewer runs in 8 of his 18 starts.  He could easily have 13 wins if not more.  63 K's isn't awe inspiring, but versus just 16 walks in 101 innings, its pretty impressive.  Francona was in a tough spot with his picks, what with the every team needs a rep rules, so Mussina is not really a snub, but I think he deserves to be there.

 

 

 
49 days ago
3
VOTE:
 
+2
 
+1
 
+0
 
-0
The Wakka Man wrote:
Why does this article not mention David Wright? Best-hitting 3B in the league! (Anyone who says "Chipper Jones" and ".380" gets a punch for being shallower than a fresh puddle.)
Shallow puddle here... Chipper has 18 homers, 50 RBI, Wright has 17 homers and 70 RBI (in 10 more games and 62 more AB's) and Chipper's BA, OBP, and Slugging are all 100 points higher than Wright's.  Chipper is the best hitting 3B in the league.  I agree that Wright belongs on the team, but over Aramis Ramirez, not Chipper. 
 
49 days ago
0
VOTE:
 
+0
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
I like the Jose Reyes one, although i think he  didn't get picked because of his bad defense this year!

Tejada made 7 errors and Reyes made 12

Also Tejada turned 9 more DP's than Reyes
 
49 days ago
1
VOTE:
 
+1
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
Buttons wrote:
Shallow puddle here... Chipper has 18 homers, 50 RBI, Wright has 17 homers and 70 RBI (in 10 more games and 62 more AB's) and Chipper's BA, OBP, and Slugging are all 100 points higher than Wright's.  Chipper is the best hitting 3B in the league.  I agree that Wright belongs on the team, but over Aramis Ramirez, not Chipper. 

Maybe Right now Jones is the best hitting Third baseman, but Wright is truly better. Especially all around. Wright is the best all around Third baseman, not only in the NL but the league. Jones will come down to earth trust me.

 

I completly agree with you that Wright deserves to be on the team over Aramis!

 
 
Preview